Brian Ruckley's News & Views

Friday, October 27, 2006

Torchwood

The first two episodes of Doctor Who's 'adult' spinoff Torchwood: Not too bad, I suppose (am I the only one who thinks alien sex vampires are a bit dull?), but got to admit I was - probably foolishly - hoping it would be brilliant. And it wasn't, really. I can't help but think it's actually a kids' show with an 'adult' skin grafted onto it. People get messily killed, there's plenty of inter- and intra-gender mouth-on-mouth action, even some bonking. But all that's just the bodywork; the chassis and engine underneath don't feel quite so grown-up. The pacing of each episode's pretty much flat-out, the plotting seems a bit reliant on people behaving like complete idiots and the characters talk and behave like unruly teenagers half the time (characteristics it shares with Spooks - a show that in the last couple of seasons seems to have given up all pretence of realism and turned into a live action cartoon, if you ask me. Which you didn't.)

Basically, it's Dr. Who with added sex and violence, which I suppose does make it an adult show, in the post-watershed kind of sense. It's got potential, so I'll give it another episode or two to really win me over. Makes me kind of miss Strange and Ultraviolet, though: brief UK efforts to do sf/f/h for grown-ups. In my possibly rose-tinted memory glasses, they both had a darker tone, a slightly more measured approach to cranking up the tension and characters who talked and behaved like adults engaged in at least vaguely serious business. Both disappeared from our screens very quickly. Not enough of us liked them, evidently. Which just goes to show ... something. That my attention span's too long, probably. Or that I'm just a grumpy old man (already? How did that happen?).

6 Comments:

Blogger Tom Rattray said...

Brian,
I watched Torchwood to check if the first 2 episodes would be ok for my 10-year old. I'm annoyed that they made me confront my own "grumpy old man" status. As Barrowman has put it in interviews, I'd have to be prepared to "answer a lot of questions". Right now, all I want to do is watch Doctor Who Extra and eat some popcorn. I even considered downloading the episodes as avi files and hand-censoring them (if I wait, someone else will do this eventually). I reckon my effort's better spent sitting her down in front of Battlestar Galactica and introducing her to politics and relationships in modern story-telling. I hate being made to feel like Angry Viewer of Tunbridge Wells.

Tom

6:21 PM  
Blogger Brian Ruckley said...

And having seen the third episode now - I think it was a slight improvement on the second, but I'm still a bit underwhelmed. I do hope they pull a really good episode out of the bag soon ...

6:41 PM  
Blogger Brian Ruckley said...

Four epidsodes down: no significant improvement to report. The patient may be in terminal decline ...

6:25 PM  
Blogger Tom Rattray said...

So I watched episode 4 to assess whether to hand-edit out all the swearing, the scenes of gore and (why stop there?) sad acting.

Here's what was left:

Ianto: She's my girlfriend!
Lisa: You will all be deleted.
Jubilee girl: Here's your pizza...
Pterodactyl: Caw!
Captain Jack: For a moment I felt so alive.

Hmmmm.
Tom

10:43 AM  
Blogger Ariel said...

I think this fellow has summed it all up quite nicely. :)

1:21 PM  
Blogger Brian Ruckley said...

Yep, that's a pretty accurate review. Despite the extensive list of flaws he mentions, he still seems to be having more fun watching it than I am, though ...

1:39 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Back to main News & Views page